Evidence Locker

The evidence locker contains two pieces of evidence regarding the murder of Tricia McMillan. It also includes images of the items that were found in the possession of the people that were in the library at the time of the murder. Click on an image to be directed to that person's police file.

Banner that reads "Centreville Police file 000223 Submitted evidence photos 001-010

A photo of Tricia McMillan, the victim, next to the contents of her pockets at the time of the murder. Items include glue sticks, pens, a pencil, paper, and a roll of tape.

[Victim, Tricia McMillan: pen set (missing one), pencil, three gluesticks, strip of paper, paperclip, roll of tape.]

A photo of Anya Nowak, next to the contents of her pockets at the time of the murder. Items include pink sticky notes, book tape, a notebook, and a pair of scissors.

[Suspect #1, Anya Nowak: Journal, pen, scissors, book tape, pink sticky notes.]

A photo of Albert Griffith, next to the contents of his pockets at the time of the murder. Items include three business cards and a scrap of paper with the number for a towing company.

[Suspect #2, Albert Griffin: three "professional Santa" business cards, one scrap of paper with phone number to towing company.]

A photo of Todd Higgins, next to the contents of his pockets at the time of the murder. Items include a large book from the Historical Collection, a wad of $1 bills, and grant paperwork.

[Suspect #3, Todd Higgins: large navy book with label that reads "Property of the Centreville Historical Collection, return to the Centreville Public Library," a wad of $1 bills, grant paperwork.]

A photo of Leroy Hartman, next to the contents of his pockets at the time of the murder. Items include a set of keys, a pen, hand sanitizer in a snowman holder, and a crumpled drawing of a socking with santa on it.

[Suspect #4, Leroy Hartman: pen, set of keys, hand sanitizer with snowman case, crumpled coloring sheet of a stocking with Santa drawn on it.]

A photo of Kelly Warner, next to the contents of her pockets at the time of the murder. Items include colored pencils, Nerf bullets, airpods, a pencil sharpener, a planet shaped notebook, and a large keyring.

[Suspect #5, Kelly Warner: Colored pencils, Nerf bullets, keyring, planet shaped notepab, bookmark, AirPods and case.]

A photo of Bayleigh Warner, next to the contents of her pockets at the time of the murder. Items include a barcode scanner, doll, toy, two glue sticks, a pen taken from the victim, three sticky note pads, paperclips, a stapler, and a necklace.

[Suspect #6, Bayleigh Warner: Barcode scanner, stapler, box of paperclips, pen (from victim's set), necklace, two gluesticks, doll, plastic toy, three pads of sticky notes.]

A photo of Lonnie Evans, next to the contents of his pockets at the time of the murder. Items include a small notebook, pen, and charging cord.

[Suspect #7, Lonnie Evans: Notebook, charging cord, pen.]

A photo of Georgia Dorsey, next to the contents of her pockets at the time of the murder. Items include a Living magazine, a crossword puzzle book, a pencil, and three butterscotch candies.

[Suspect #8, Georgia Dorsey: Martha Stewart Living magazine, crossword puzzle book (filled in in pen), pencil, three butterscotch candies.]

A photo of Joseph Spencer, next to the contents of his pockets at the time of the murder. Items include a Star Trek wallet, two blue pens, a staple remover, a small notebook, a black paperclip, and a gluestick. One of the pens is broken.

[Suspect #9, Joseph Spencer: Star Trek wallet, small notepad, two blue pens (one broken), glue stick, staple remover, paperclip.]

Content warning: The included crime scene photos are graphic in nature. Please do not view if you are under the age of 13 or are sensitive to violent images. Please hover your mouse over the Centreville Police File image below to see a more detailed content warning.

Banner that reads "Centreville Police file 000223 Submitted crime scene evidence 001-002

Photo of an evidence bag, which contains a cookie with red frosting that was found on top of the victim's body. A bite has been taken.

Photo of an evidence bag, which contains the knife used to kill the victim. The knife is blue and has "falalalala" written on the blade.

A square photo of a blurred out library floor plan, over which are the words "Return to Start" in black text

A blurred out photo with police lights in the background. In the foreground is a strand of yellow caution tape that reads "Police Do Not Cross." Over it are the words "Crime Scene Photos"

Photo of a large filing cabinet, with the words "Police Files" centered on the image.

A landscape gray background with strips of yellow caution tape on either side. In the middle are the words "Think you've solved the mystery? Then click here!"

By RachaelR on December 2, 2020